Criticism to paper of V.A. Popov «About current paradigm of mineralogy as a reflection of crystal anatomy laws»
Yu.L. Voytekhovsky
UDК 549.0
Abstract
About authors
References
Abstract
After D.P. Grigor’ev, A.G. Zhabin and N.L. Yuskin passed away, the discussion of topical methodic mineralogical problems became secondary. V.A. Popov puts attention to these problems and suggests their solutions. This is an undoubted urgency of his paper, however, the paper raises several questions.
About authors
Yu.L. Voytekhovsky, Geological Institute Kola RC RAN, Russia, Apatity, Fersman str., 14; woyt@geoksc.ru
References
- Vernadsky V.I. (1960) [Selected works]. Vol. V M., USSR Academy of Sciences, 211 p. (in Russian)
- Wolfe G.V. (1922) [Life of crystals]. M., 92 p. (in Russian)
- Zhabin A.G. (1976) [Life of minerals]. M., «Soviet Russia», 220 p. (in Russian)
- Korago A.A. (1992) [Introduction to biomineralogy]. St-Petersburg, Nedra, 280 p. (in Russian)
- Povarennych M.Yu. (2016) [Crystal-chemical paradigm of modern mineralogy and one of the pillars of Russian Academy of Sciences of the Ukrainian SSR A.S. Povarennych. What next?] Uralskiy geologicheskiy zhurnal [Ural-sky geological journal], (3), 18-32. (in Russian)
Stenon N. (1957) [On a solid that naturally contained within a solid]. M., AN SSSR, 31 p. (in Russian) - Yushkin N.P. (2006) [Science: work, search, life]. Yekaterinburg, UB RAS, Institute of Geology, 463 p. (in Russian)
МINERALOGY № 2 2018